N. LONDONDERRY TWP.
Monday, December 26, 2005
BY BARBARA MILLER
Of Our Palmyra Bureau
A Lebanon County man who found a rifle bullet hole in his house and
another in his shed thinks it's time to ban rifle hunting in North
Kenneth Neiswender of the 700 block of Eisenhower Road, who found
the holes over the last five or six years, said he's afraid someone is
going to get killed.
Whether shotguns and muzzleloaders pose less risk to the public
than rifles will be explored in a study that will start in January,
paid for by the state.
Allowing only shotguns or muzzleloaders would be wise, Neiswender
said. A rifle bullet can go more than a mile, while a shotgun slug
only 150 yards, he said.
"I hunt with a rifle myself, but this is getting out of hand," he
told the township supervisors Dec. 19.
"We're looking into it," said Ron Fouche, the chairman of the
supervisors. He added, "I'm not sure a municipality can do it. It may
have to be the county."
In Pennsylvania, only the state Game Commission can regulate
hunting and trapping, said Jerry Feaser, a commission spokesman.
Municipalities can limit the discharge of firearms, but they don't
have authority to regulate activity being done as part of lawful
hunting, Feaser said. Only the Game Commission or the Legislature can
ban rifle hunting, and several counties persuaded state authorities to
Rifle hunting is banned in Allegheny, Bucks, Chester, Delaware,
Montgomery and Philadelphia counties.
Feaser said the Game Commission has studied whether shotguns are
safer than rifles and concluded they aren't necessarily.
The commission recognized it didn't have the expertise to analyze
all the data, which led to the current study, he said.
"We want to make our decision based on fact," Feaser said.
The $99,000 study, to be conducted by MountainTop Technologies Inc.
of Johnstown, will include creating a computer model to analyze
incidents of people and property being hit by projectiles, said John
Rowe, the chief analyst for the state Legislative Budget and Finance
Committee. It should be done by mid-2006, Rowe said.
North Londonderry Police Chief Kevin Snyder said he believes
development is starting to encroach on hunting areas in many parts of
"The township is not going to ban hunting," Snyder said. "But I'm a
hunter, and I'm a person who wouldn't have a problem" if rifle hunting
"On the other hand, it comes down to being a responsible hunter. If
you're responsible, you can safely use rifles in this area yet. It may
mean passing up a deer because it's running toward a roadway. If every
hunter would do that, we wouldn't have a problem. There are hunters
who take chances and ruin it for everyone," he said.
Snyder said he knew of only one such incident in the township this
year. A man was charged with trespassing and Game Commission
violations after shooting a six-point buck several weeks ago on Pennsy
Supply quarry property east of Forge Road.
Michael Orwan of Hummelstown, who teaches competitive rifle
shooting for the Palmyra Sportsmen's Club in North Londonderry Twp.,
said he wouldn't oppose a ban on rifle hunting if there's a "serious
"Let's face it, people come before killing the critters," Orwan
But he said some shotguns can be modified to fire 1,000 yards,
which is nearly the range of a rifle.
Another club member, Sam Shrefler of Annville, who hunts in western
Pennsylvania, said he believes southern Lebanon County would be suited
to a ban on rifle hunting, but not the northern part of the county,
which is more sparsely populated.
He also would oppose expanding the ban to the northern part of the
Rowe said the Legislature began looking at expanding rifle bans
after two nonhunters in western Pennsylvania were shot and killed by
hunters in 1996. In 2004, a pregnant woman in Lehigh County survived
being shot while sitting in a car in a driveway.
BARBARA MILLER: 832-2090 or [email protected]
©2005 The Patriot-News
© 2005 PennLive.com All Rights Reserved.