AFMA Americans
for Medical Advancement
March 2006
Don't surgeons train on animals before operating on humans?
Many surgeons do trials on pigs and other lab animals. Many other
surgeons - both present day and past - have admitted that work on animals
confuses procedures. Even with limited medical knowledge, common sense
suggests that orthopedic surgeries will be much different in a dog, for
example, than in a human. Ophthalmologists perfected radial keratotomy on
rabbits, then tried them out on humans. Only after completely blinding
several humans, did they finally correct the procedure.
The field of neurosurgery offers another example. Extracranial-intracranial
(EC-IC) bypass procedures for inoperable carotid artery disease were tested
and perfected on dogs and rabbits. Neurosurgeons performed thousands of
EC-ICs before it was discovered the operation did more harm than good. More
patients died or suffered strokes because of the operation than were saved
as a result of it.
Transplantation surgeries are much the same story. Hundreds and hundreds of
cats, dogs, pigs and primates have been sacrificed as surgeons tried to
fashion surgeries that move organs from one creature to another. No matter
the number of practice surgeries on animals, the first human operations
fail. Carrying the animal data over to the human body always proves
deceiving. Only conducting procedures on humans provides dependable
techniques.
Return to Animal Rights Articles
Read more at Alternatives to Animal Testing, Experimentation and Dissection