Marc Bekoff, Ph.D.,
Psychology Today / Animal Emotions
December 2017
I asked members of my "Animal cognition, animal emotions, and compassionate conservation" group, an international array of people with diverse interests, to respond in 12 or fewer words: "How can we make the world better for nonhuman animals?"
Marc and the lovely Geraldine...
Last week I posted an essay called
"How to Give Dogs the Best Lives Possible in a Human World" in which
researchers and trainers weighed in on how we can make the world better for
dogs. This idea was was originally posted by Dr. Zazie Todd on her very
informative Companion Animal Psychology website.
I decided to play off of this theme and generalized the question to read,
"How can we make the world better for nonhuman animals?" I asked members of
my "Animal cognition, animal emotions, and compassionate conservation"
group, an international array of people with diverse interests, to respond
in 12 or fewer words. I chose the number of words based on a wonderful book
called The Best Advice in Six Words edited by Larry Smith for which
numerous other people and I were asked to write six and only six words of
advice, nothing more and nothing less. At first I thought it would be easy,
but it took me a while to come up with something with which I was happy.
Others also were fooled by Mr. Smith's seemingly "simple" request.
Here are some of the responses, in alphabetical order, from people with very
different backgrounds and interests. They make for a unique, fascinating,
and wide-ranging read on different ways to make the world better for
nonhuman animals.
Never remain silent; use your voice to protest the injustices they endure.
-- Cheryl Abbate
Eat plants! Stop eating animals and exploiting females for milk and eggs. --
Carol J. Adams, author of The Sexual Politics of Meat
Because animals' lives matter, I'd remove all human supremacists from the
planet. -- Carol Ames
Contemplate human achievement as a geologic stratum marking the 6th mass
extinction. -- Robert Anderson (The Other Moral Species)
Grant them the rights and protection to live a life worth living. -- Liv
Baker, PhD, Institute for Compassionate Conservation, Executive Director
Treat them as if you live in their own paws or appendages. -- Barbara Hardy
Beierl
Take time to spread global peace for all individual nonhuman animals. --
Marc Bekoff
Understand that each is a sentient individual who wants to live! -- Valerie
Belt
Ecosystem function, rather than species conservation, should guide
conservation action. -- Dror Ben-Ami, Founder Compassionate Conservation
Middle East
Humanely decrease the human population and encourage sharp reductions in all
consumption. -- Sarah M. Bexell, Institute for Human-Animal Connection,
University of Denver
Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. -- Laura Bridgeman,
director, Sonar.
Interfaith communities practicing compassion for all sentient beings. --
Judy Carman, Interfaith Vegan Coalition, In Defense of Animals
Self-care tools for animal activists on the front lines. -- Fleur Dawes,
Communications Director, In Defense of Animals
Systematic change within academia and the justice system can impact animal
lives. -- Margo DeMello, Animals & Society Institute
Reconcile that the planet belongs to all species and humans are just guests.
-- Dr. Sara Dubois, BC SPCA Chief Scientific Officer & University of British
Columbia Adjunct Professo
Make better people. -- Randall Eaton
Replace anthropocentric thinking with life-centric thinking: consider
animals and environment in decisions. -- Anne Fawcett, Australian
veterinarian, editor of Veterinary Ethics: Navigating Tough Cases
Kill disillusionment, not animals; go vegan! -- Nicole Felts, Why go
vegan?
Consider their perspectives and treat them like they matter. -- Hope
Ferdowsian, MD, MPH, FACP, FACPM, and author of Phoenix Zones: Where
Strength Is Born and Resilience Lives (Chicago Press, Spring 2018)
Accept that they are not ours to sell, kill, eat, or wear. -- Andrew Fenton,
Department of Philosophy, Dalhousie University (author of "Decisional
Authority and Animal Research Subjects." In The Routledge Handbook of
Philosophy of Animal Minds, edited by Kristin Andrews and Jacob Beck.
New York: Routledge, 2018: 475-84.)
Humans must come to perceive animals as relatives, not resources. -- Richard
Foster, Editor, Daily Kumquat
We share this planet with other sentient beings and must learn to coexist,
-- Camilla Fox, Founder & Executive Director, Project Coyote
Realize that our assumption of separation and even superiority is just that.
-- Howard Garrett, Orca Network
The greatest danger to our future is apathy. -- Jane Goodall, PhD, DBE,
Founder - the Jane Goodall Institute & UN Messenger of Peace
Respecting animals wildness in a biocentric vision and not an
anthropocentric one. -- Chiara Grasso - Psychologist and Ethologist
Act like all life forms around you are imbued with inherent dignity. --
Marielle Grenade-Willis, Friends of Animals
Stop measuring worthiness by braininess, stop eating meat, and just be kind.
-- David Hancocks, architect, former zoo and museum director
Never harm a sentient being needlessly and always help if you can. --Stevan
Harnad, Professor of Cognitive Science, UQŔM, Editor, Animal Sentience
Make animal-human relationships the topic of courses in secondary education.
-- Shonna Hawkins
Consider that they, like us, are living, feeling souls. -- Michael Jawer
Seek to listen to and learn from nonhuman animals. -- Ann Johnson, Artist
and journalist, Editor, Quaker Concern for Animals Newsletter
Love our neighbors of all species as ourselves -- Rev. Dr. LoraKim Joyner,
One Earth Conservation
Realizing that you have the power to bring positive change around you. --
Anna Katogiritis, President, Jane Goodall's Roots & Shoots Greece
Twelve-step support for everyone to adopt a plant-based diet. -- Marilyn
Kroplick, MD, President, In Defense of Animals, Carnivores Anonymous
Rewild woodland by creating secure enclosures for wolfdogs who cannot be
rehired. -- Simon Leadbetter
Stop considering humans superior; we are guests in animals' home: the Earth.
-- Christian Lenzi, Ethologist
Do unto nonhuman animals as you would have others do unto you. -- Beth
Levine
Integrating vegan values into our spiritual practices. -- Lisa Levinson,
Sustainable Activism Campaign Director, In Defense of Animals and Vegan
Spirituality
Let's increase and support awareness, education, funding for protection and
diversity. -- Paul Mack, architect
Stop eating, hunting, killing, harming animals and make human birth control
mandatory. -- Sally Mackler, Carnivore Advocate, Predator Defense
Define yourself by how you treat all animals including humans. -- Thomas D.
Mangelsen, Photographer, Images of Nature
Embrace them with all the compassion given to us by Mother Earth. -- Natasha
Milne, photographer
Grant them the rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.-- Dr.
Betty Moss
Treat all fellow animals the way you wish to be treated yourself. -- Val
Murray, Justice for BC Grizzlies, Victoria, BC, Canada
Become "The Greatest Generation" and become vegan and stop animal holocaust.
-- Debbie Nelson
Recognizing animals have their own destiny, not what we choose for them. --
Jennifer O’Connor, Senior Writer, PETA Foundation
At each mealtime, consume compassionate calories that fuel mercy not
cruelty. -- Alice Oven, MSc Animal Welfare, Ethics and Law student at
University of Winchester
Not always simple or easy, compassionate conservation makes all lives
better. -- Paul C. Paquet, Raincoast Conservation Foundation, Canada
Treat them as family members, not objects you own. Judy Paulsen
To tell the truth, all peoples, animals and plants need a voice. -- David
Paxton
Remember: Each life is precious to the one in possession of it. -- Jessica
Pierce
Ask zoos to stop exhibiting nonhuman animals, and to rewrite their paradigm.
-- Colleen Plumb, artist, Thirty Times a Minute
Animal lives matter, sharing not sparing, anthropocene is here, prevent
extinction. -- Daniel Ramp, Centre For Compassionate Conservation
Remember our similarities, differences, and shared capacity for joy, pain
and love. -- Professor Angelique Richardson, University of Exeter
Embrace every one life, as kindly, thoughtfully, compassionately, as your
own. -- Jill Robinson MBE, Dr med vet hc, Hon LLD, Founder & CEO Animals
Asia Foundation
Inspire reverence, demand respect, and restore biosynergy among all living
beings. -- Anthony L Rose, Ph.D., The Biosynergy Institute, See: Rose, A.L.
Biosynergy. Article in Fuentes & Riley (Eds), International Encyclopedia
of Primatology. Wiley, New York., 2017
Give Rights to Nature: plastic in seas and felling trees: A CRIME. --
Jessica and Myla Fallon Rothwell
Change human perceptions to include the immense, intrinsic value other
species. -- Kira Sadler, Co-Director, Voices for Biodiversity
Nonhumans, or n’humans, need room to live in viable numbers: habitat. --
Carl Safina
Codifying (in law) non-human animal interests in living and freedom from
harm. -- Francisco J. Santiago-Ávila
Stop killing and eating them. -- John Sorenson, PhD., Professor, Department
of Sociology, Brock University
Always remind people about real consequences to others about their personal
choices. -- Veda Stram, All-Creatures
Consider their needs, and how these can best be fulfilled. -- Lisa
Tenpin-Dolma, Author, and principal of The International School for Canine
Psychology & Behaviour
Shift our human paradigm from dominance to respect and understanding
differences. -- Polly Thurston
Acknowledge that all animals relate to signs, and respect their semiotic
agency. -- Morton Třnnessen, Norway; Recent co-authored book (Open Access):
Animal Umwelten in a Changing World: Zoosemiotic Perspectives
(Tartu University Press 2016)
Learn about the animals in your care, and be kind to them. -- Zazie Todd,
PhD; Companion Animal Psychology
We must stop denying the complex inner lives of other animals. -- Emily
Tronetti, CPDT-KA, MSc in Anthrozoology Candidate at Canisius College
Designate habitat off-limits to all humans. -- Mike Vandeman
To make people recognize the similarities between nonhuman animals and human
animals. -- Meggan Vandermast
Retract the human enterprise until the rest of nature rebounds and
flourishes. -- Ian Whyte
Earth’s healing can only happen when we understand; We are all one. -- Wendy
Wyatt
Some repeated themes from a unique and diverse international audience
Many thanks to everyone who took the time to respond. A number of
repeated themes emerged from these one-liners, and of course, there's
considerable overlap among them. I'm pleased to note that these responses
come from a very diverse audience of people from different countries, some
of whom make their livings studying other animals or working on their
behalf, and others who really and truly care about the state of the animals
in 2017 and do all they can when they are able to do so for other animals
and their homes. Everyone single individual can make a difference.
Repeated themes include: there are too many people; we should consider
becoming vegans and pay attention to who we eat; we need to save habitats
save habitats and animals' homes; humane education is key as is
compassionate conservation based on the principles "First do no harm" and
the lives of all individuals matter; all individuals need to be
respected; silence is deadly; maintaining hope in difficult times; animals
aren't objects; we need to give serious attention to "the golden rule"; we
need to try to take animals point of view; coexistence has to be our goal;
sentience is critical to consider when we decide how to treat other animals;
it's important maintain biodiversity; hierarchies in which we place
ourselves on the top and separate from other animals don't work; human
superiority, exceptionalism, and domination are the wrong ways to go; the
importance of rewilding nature and ourselves and of reconnecting with other
nature; spirituality; interfaith cooperation; recognizing continuity between
human and other animals; and there's a need for major reform across the
board in venues in which animals are used and abused.
There's a lot of food for thought here for people studying nonhuman-human relationships, including conservation psychologists, sociologists, and anthrozoologists.
Let's stop pretending we don't know what other animals want and need: They do not want to suffer and die
As a biologist, I realize there aren't "higher" and "lower" animals, and
labels like higher and lower really don't mean anything at all and are
frequently used to justify the mistreatment of lower animals because the
word lower far too easily slides into "less intelligent," "less feeling," or
less valuable." So, are humans exceptional and unique? Yes, but so too are
other animals. And, just like us, animals want to live in peace and safety —
so let's stop pretending we don't know what they want and need. They do not
want to die and surely do not want to be subjected to brutal torture before
they succumb.
Nonhumans clearly need much more respect, compassion, and Freedom (with a
capital F). I often like to remind people of the late Gretchen Wyler's apt
statement that "Cruelty can't stand the spotlight" and that nonhumans need
the voice of every single person, each of whom can make positive differences
in their lives. I also often go back to what I call the 12 P's of rewilding
(which began with only eight), namely, being proactive, positive,
persistent, patient, peaceful, practical, powerful, passionate, playful,
present, principled, and proud when working on behalf of other animals.
It's important to be nice and kind to those with whom you disagree and move
on. Sometimes it's just better to let something go, so pick your "battles"
carefully and don't waste time and energy. Don't waste time "fighting"
people who won't change and don't let them deflect attention from the
important work that needs to be done. Don't get in long-drawn out arguments
with people who want you to waste precious time and energy fighting them,
time and energy that must go into working for animals and earth and peace
and justice. The bottom line is don't waste time bickering and keep moving
forward.
And, while we're at it, let's be sure that youngsters know just what we are
doing so they will model their behavior on ours and then, they too, can
continue to do the good work that is necessary for our magnificent planet
and for all beings to thrive and to look forward to, and joyously welcome
in, many new days. Teach the children well, for they are the ambassadors for
a more harmonious, peaceful, compassionate, and gentle world.
We are animals and therein lies hope for a better future for all
It's clear that nonhumans need all the help they can get, and I learned a lot from reading the responses that came in and by rereading them many times. All in all, we can always do more for other animals, and I hope that as we move into 2018 we will see further changes in how they are treated in the wide variety of venues in which billions are used and abused globally. And, the ideas presented above, are a solid launching pad from which we can and must do something for the fascinating animals with whom we share our magnificent planet.
I truly look forward to a significantly better and more hopeful state for the animals in 2018 and beyond, and for everyone who works to support other animals and their homes in an increasingly human-dominated world, I offer a heartfelt thank you.
Return to Animal Rights Articles