The compassionate move comes after modern research into animal welfare has shown that elephants do not cope well in captivity, with zoo enclosures unable to meet the complex needs of elephants.
Osh at The Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee. Credit: Oakland Zoo
Oakland Zoo’s last remaining elephant has safely arrived at his new
sanctuary home.
Osh the African elephant had been living in a large 6.5-acre
enclosure at the zoo.
But in a statement issued earlier this year, Oakland Zoo announced
that the 30-year-old elephant would be relocated to a sanctuary, as
the zoo said it could no longer offer the optimal welfare and social
needs required for elephants.
“This space is not enough for the elephants’ social complexity that
we think is necessary,” a representative of the zoo told ABC 7 News
in July.
Now, the zoo’s animal care team have successfully made the 46-hour
long road trip to carefully deliver Osh to his new home at The
Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee.
With Osh’s departure, Oakland Zoo is now without elephants for the
first time in 75 years. The zoo says it has no immediate plans to
procure another elephant, and that it will take this time to
“reimagine the future of the elephant habitat”.
Osh interacting with new companion, Artie, at The Elephant Sanctuary
in Tennessee. Credit: Oakland Zoo
Animal welfare group In Defense of Animals applauded the zoo’s
commitment to prioritizing Osh’s health and needs.
“Osh’s release to sanctuary marks a watershed moment in the
evolution of zoos, and a dawning of the next generation of more
compassionate, elephant-free zoos that embrace modern scientific
understanding, seek to engage rather than entertain, and prioritize
animals over profit”, said Dr. Marilyn Kroplick, president of In
Defense of Animals.
According to Dr. Kroplick, Oakland Zoos is only the second US zoo to
concede that its comparatively massive 6.5 acre elephant exhibit is
not enough room to meet the needs of the world’s largest land
mammals.
Lack of space for elephants in captivity has become an increasing
concern for Dr. Kroplick and other animal welfare experts.
The issue was highlighted in a recent study co-authored by renowned
wildlife biologist Dr. Keith Lindsay, which compared the movement
ranges of elephants in the wild and in zoos. Its findings show that
wild elephants evolved to live in spaces 1,000 to a million times
bigger than even a large zoo enclosure of 10 hectares (4.7 acres).
Credit: In Defense of Animals
“Elephants need vast landscapes to roam, forage, explore new
territory, and find places to retreat from conflicts or when they
don’t want company. These activities are vital for their mental and
physical health”, explains Courtney Scott, Elephant Consultant for
In Defense of Animals. “Zoos fail elephants largely by lack of vast
roaming spaces, making elephants age faster and die at half the age
of their wild counterparts.”
This sentiment echoes mounting scientific data and research suggests
that zoos cannot fully meet the needs of elephants. Welfare experts
say that most elephants in North American and European zoos
demonstrate stereotypic behaviors, and suffer from psychological
problems.
A comprehensive report by animal welfare group Born Free into the
state of elephant captivity recently highlighted further issues in
the zoo industry too. This includes an alarmingly high infant
mortality in breeding operations, with 40 percent of infant
elephants in zoos dying before reaching the age of five.
The report also pointed out the impact of zoos on wild populations,
with the number of captive elephants increasing over the last 40
years mainly through the import of captured wild elephants.
In a sign of positive progress, this research and ongoing work by
animal welfare and wildlife groups is leading to increased public
awareness of the ethics of keeping animals in captivity.
Oakland Zoo’s compassionate relocation of Osh, for example, makes it
the 41st zoo in the US to close or pledge to close its elephant
exhibit.