Feel/feeling/felt would be fine for replacing all the ambiguous s-words (sense, sensor, sensation…) and dispelling their ambiguities.
“Sentient” is the right word for “conscious.” It means being able
to feel anything at all – whether positive, negative or neutral,
faint or flagrant, sensory or semantic.
For ethics, it’s the negative feelings that matter. But determining
whether an organism feels anything at all (the other-minds problem)
is hard enough without trying to speculate about whether there exit
species that can only feel neutral (“unvalenced”) feelings. (I doubt
that +/-/= feelings evolved separately, although their
valence-weighting is no doubt functionally dissociable, as in the
Melzack/Wall gate-control theory of pain.)
The word “sense” in English is ambiguous, because it can mean both
felt sensing and unfelt “sensing,” as in an electronic device like a
sensor, or a mechanical one, like a thermometer or a thermostat, or
even a biological sensor, like an in-vitro retinal cone cell, which,
like photosensitive film, senses and reacts to light, but does not
feel a thing (though the brain it connects to might).
To the best of our knowledge so far, the phototropisms,
thermotropisms and hydrotropisms of plants, even the ones that can
be modulated by their history, are all like that too: sensing and
reacting without feeling, as in homeostatic systems or
servomechanisms.
Feel/feeling/felt would be fine for replacing all the ambiguous
s-words (sense, sensor, sensation…) and dispelling their
ambiguities.
(Although “feeling” is somewhat biased toward emotion (i.e., +/-
“feelings”), it is the right descriptor for neutral feelings too,
like warmth, movement, or touch, which only become +/- at extreme
intensities.)
The only thing the f-words lack is a generic noun for “having the
capacity too feel” as a counterpart for the noun sentience itself
(and its referent). (As usual, German has a candidate:
Gefühlsfähigkeit.)
And all this, without having to use the
weasel-word
“conscious/consciousness,” for which the f-words are a healthy
antidote, to keep us honest, and coherent…